Perhaps you could bash a Vinnie out of Connor?
I've seen it done, it's not so farfetched.
Two of those Jameses though, wow
In a (somewhat old) CGI episode called "Tickled Pink", James gets a pink undercoat and attempts to hide from the other engines, embarrassed to be seen. Would you mind repainting one of these Jameses to look like that? As WoodWheel said, Connor (not "Conner") could be used to make Vinnie, but I feel he should instead be used to make Southern Pacific 4449 (Daylight) or Shooting Star Gordon (with a normal Gordon face). Vinnie could instead be made from a TrackMaster Connor, since the Plarail version is in a more accurate scale and the TrackMaster is too thin.
Thanks guys for the ideas. One of my thought for one of the James is to do a Black edition, similar to the one released with the Green Thomas set. These are the 50 phrase engines as well.
How about a Military James in Camo???