Rarest Plarail/Tomy Trains

huh, how did you come to find out about it

It was on eBay 9 years ago.

Yes Clear brown Annie would be in the top 5...
#1. Is the promotional TrackMaster Lion of Sodor statue flatbed.
#2. Gold Annie & Clarabel
#3. Clear brown Annie
#4. Silver Thomas' steelworks foundry cars
#5. Hector's red coach
....after that I would nominate;
Big Slash Victor's red breakdown crane, The Pop up fireworks van, Pop up dinosaur car, Flip up Refreshment stand, Thomas' stinky cheese van, Dodge's white van...

Sorry to bump up this thread, but could someone confirm what Hector's red coach looks like? Does it look like Oliver's coach, but with a dark grey roof? Is it particularly rare based on the fact that that variant of the Hector and Thomas wasn't sold in large quantities? Thanks for any insight BPT folks can offer!

[Super]

I am not sure if this is what Muddy refers to but there is this

Yes it’s the same as Oliver’s coaches...the only way for it to be of any extra value though is for it to still be contained within an unopened Hector Greatest Moments.

Update for new Top 12 Rarest Tomy/HitToys/FisherPrice TrackMaster line:
1. TOMY Gold Thomas
2. TOMY Silver Thomas
3. TOMY Blushing face Thomas
4. HitToys RC Flip-Face Celebration Thomas
5. HitToys Thomas w/Hector & red coach (Greatest Moments)
6. HitToys Alfie
7. TOMY Clear brown Annie
8. Yujin (licensed by TOMY) Percy candy train
9. TOMY Red Bulgy w/service window
10. FisherPrice Monty
11. TOMY American accent T’nA James
12. TOMY Thumper
Honorable mentions:
Flip-Face Toby, Plarail: Front hook Splatter, Oliver, Winston, Bash, Chuffing Annie, Wobbly wheeled Troublesome truck.

[Super]

Thanks for your updated List Muddy.

Besides the Auction you won and 2 other single listings, I have never seen another Clear Brown Annie...ever.

Do you have picture or what is Red Bulgy w/service window?

Yes, we’ve made a couple videos about it... https://youtu.be/gvTQudiJrJg

...and there is yet a 4th variant of Bulgy. :O
https://youtu.be/la3GG--xX2o

2nd link broken. Noticed it same body as green bulgy.